We Become whatever we Copy
We take our experience of consciousness for granted, but people who lack human nuturing and language as children experience a very different version of consciousness and reality.Victor, illustrated here, was a twelve-year-old boy who was captured in France in 1799. Victor was naked and mute. He acted like an animal, and his body was scarred from years of living in the wild. Victor was tutored for several years by a resourceful young medical student named Jean-Marc Itard. Itard taught him to understand basic speech, although Victor only learned to say two words. Interestingly, Victor was completely comfortable while naked in cold weather. He would even leap about in the snow and throw it up in the air in joy, completely oblivious to the cold.
More recently, in 1991, authorities in Ukraine discovered Oxana, an eight year-old girl who had been raised by stray dogs since she was three years old.With intensive speech therapy she was able to acquire basic language skills. However, at age twenty-two she remained developmentally a six year-old. Oxana demonstrated her dog-like heritage for reporter Elizabeth Grice from the U.K. Telegraph. Grice wrote:
"She bounds along on all fours through long grass, panting towards water with her tongue hanging out. When she reaches the tap she paws at the ground with her forefeet, drinks noisily with her jaws wide and lets the water cascade over her head. Up to this point, you think the girl could be acting--but the moment she shakes her head and neck free of droplets, exactly like a dog when it emerges from a swim, you get a creepy sense that this is something beyond imitation. Then, she barks. The furious sound she makes is not like a human being pretending to be a dog. It is a proper, chilling, canine burst of aggression and it is coming from the mouth of a young woman, dressed in T-shirt and shorts."
Notes
1. Helen Keller. The World I Live In. New York: Century. 1904, 1908. Pages 113-14.
2. _____. "Secret of the Wild Child." PBS Nova. Airdate: March 4, 1997. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/transcripts/2112gchild.html. Accessed July 1, 2007.
3. _____. "Hello mutter, hello Fido." DogsInTheNews.com. http://dogsinthenews.com/stories/060925b.php. September 25,
2006. Accessed February 24, 2008.
4. Elizabeth Grice. "Cry of an enfant sauvage." Telegraph. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/arts/main.jhtml?xml=/arts/2006/07/17/ftdog17.xml. June 7, 2006. Accessed February 24, 2008.